Episode 2.20 and 2.21 “The Maquis, parts 1&2” (Mel’s review)
Neflix description (part 1): The worst is feared when a Cardassian freighter, the Bok’Nor, explodes while departing the station.
What exactly is “the worst” here? I mean, I know what they’re referring to, but just based on this description it could mean anything.
Netflix description (part 2): Sisko, Kira, and Bashir are held in a Maquis camp, but Gul Dukat is not there.
This might be my second favorite description yet (right after the one for “Cardassians”). “…but Gul Dukat is not there"—couldn’t that be said about episodes he doesn’t appear in? The description for "Blood Oath" could be amended thus: "The relative calm of Deep Space Nine is shattered by the arrival of three Klingon warriors, but Gul Dukat is not there.” Actually, I demand they start tacking that on to the end of the episode descriptions for every show on Netflix.
______________________________
Time for a shameful confession: I was (more than) a little tipsy when we watched this two parter. I’m not sure why I thought that would be a good idea. Goodness, this is embarrassing. Anyway, I found my notes were of little use to me, so I re-watched the second part in order to be able to write something about this two-parter.
While I enjoyed other scenes in these two episodes, the entire 2 hours could have just been Avery Brooks and Marc Alaimo in a room talking/arguing and it would have been just as good. These episodes basically belong to the two of them.
One of the things that I like about this episode is that after finding out that his old friend Cal Hudson has joined the Maquis, Sisko doesn’t give up on him. He doesn’t immediately mention it to Starfleet, and he holds on to Cal’s uniform. I feel like this is such a Sisko thing to do. He even listened to Cal and considered his opinion. Sisko is very good about hearing people out (particularly those he trusts), even if he doesn’t agree with what they have to say.
Aside from the scenes with him and Dukat, my favorite Sisko scene is probably the one with Kira after the visit from Admiral Nechayev. He’s been angered by what the admiral had to say and tells Kira, “It’s easy to be a saint in paradise.” This line is one of the reasons why DS9 is my favorite Trek. I love that it wasn’t afraid to show the flaws of Starfleet/the Federation.
We get a lot of Dukat in this episode, and he is fantastic to watch. Just letting him—or pretty much any Cardassian—talk (more like monologue!) makes for great viewing. We learn that Central Command isn’t very fond of Dukat, and therefore the air of importance he always tries to project is just in his own mind.
I said that my original notes weren’t of much use to me. This is because I mostly just wrote responses to bits of dialogue. Here are a few:
- Dukat has 7 children. That he knows of!
- Sisko in lederhosen! Please!
- Jake is watching Bajoran women coming off a transport. Shouldn’t Dukat be racing down there to join him?
Other thoughts:
- Both Marc Alaimo and Bernie Casey appear in these episodes. Nearly twenty years prior, the two of them appeared in the movie Dr. Black and Mr. Hyde (sometimes listed as Dr. Black and Mr. White). I apologize for the poor quality of these screenshots, but I could only find the film on YouTube.




